2014-12-16

Superbowl XLIX Projection, Week 15, Final

New England over Seattle

Yesterday I got a comment asking about the ridiculous looking ranking of having Dallas below Houston, despite the 3-game difference in record, and Dallas having actually beaten Houston.

To address the second point first, Dallas won by 3 in overtime, so that's practically a tie in terms of using head-to-head to determine who is better.

As for the Strength column, that's determined purely by points scored and points allowed, which is basically Bill James' baseball formula for determined a team's Pythagorean Winning Percentage. The theory goes that a team that allows about as many points as it scores will be about .500 in its future games, regardless of if it managed to pull off a bunch of small wins and few huge losses, or vice versa. That's why 7-7 San Francisco is listed at .460, but 7-7 Miami is at .554, and 7-7 Houston is at .601. A team could even be 1-13 at this point, but if they won a game 62-0 and lost the rest 2-0, they'd be near the top. The actual formula I use is somewhat complex, involving exponents, league-wide points per game, and regressing to .500 based on how far into the season it is, but there is a simplification that can be made for purposes of comparing 2 teams: the higher a team's pf/pa ratio, the higher their strength will be, where pf = points for, and pa = points against.

Houston has scored 324 point against 277 allowed. Dallas has scored 381, but allowed 328. That gives Houston a slightly higher ratio of pf/pa, and the corollary to that is that their strength is at .601, where Dallas is at .596. Houston's points have not been distributed as favorably for them, though, so they've won 3 less games than Dallas. The meaning of those strengths in my projections is that Houston would win 50.52% of the simulations if they played again. That's just barely an advantage.

One caveat to mention is that this is supposed to represent an average of the teams over their last 14 games, so the average Houston lineup over the last 14 games would be slightly favored to win over the average Dallas lineup. This doesn't mean the Houston lineup with the 3rd string QB would be favored to win this week against the mostly-intact Dallas lineup. It does mean that Arizona, even at 11-3, is likely even worse than their 11th-best ranking, since they're now on QB number 3 as well.

Hopefully all that made some sense. I realize I did a little hand-waving to get from pf/pa to strength, but I didn't want to post a full screen worth of LaTeX equations to show my work.

TEAMRecordStrengthDivPlyffWCQtrSemiChamp
NE11-30.744++98.91761.42937.15022.659
BAL9-50.70626.98773.90944.15021.81111.7486.630
SEA10-40.70349.70194.79680.68548.57828.43414.621
GB10-40.68151.02996.99778.03644.58124.50911.958
IND10-40.679++57.80528.71413.9667.448
DEN11-30.656++98.50450.43222.15911.254
KC8-60.649-35.86118.7718.0913.7101.855
BUF8-60.630-17.4828.3503.6111.5880.763
PHI9-50.61640.60445.44721.70610.1034.7822.000
DET10-40.60648.97194.09469.01033.32914.8916.091
ARI11-30.60450.299+82.11636.82416.7056.794
HOU7-70.601-4.2831.9370.6840.3060.138
DAL10-40.59659.39668.66636.49716.3687.3542.936
PIT9-50.58933.70772.21232.96712.3654.8642.127
MIA7-70.554-0.0520.0200.0060.0030.001
CIN9-4-10.54839.30778.34131.73310.7843.8001.510
SD8-60.520-17.8596.8462.0730.7060.262
STL6-80.487------
NO6-80.48257.40357.40319.4306.5132.2030.653
ATL5-90.46228.83028.8309.2342.9290.9380.263
SF7-70.460------
NYG5-90.456------
MIN6-80.455------
CLE7-70.446------
CAR5-8-10.36313.76713.7673.2860.7740.1840.038
CHI5-90.304------
WAS3-110.283------
TB2-120.281------
NYJ3-110.244------
TEN2-120.214------
JAC2-120.195------
OAK2-120.193------

First to 10% chance of Superbowl Win: Cincinnati (Week 3, Sunday)

First to 80% chance of Playoffs: Cincinnati (Week 3, Sunday)
First to 90% chance of Playoffs: Indianapolis (Week 7, Sunday)
First to 99% chance of Playoffs: Arizona (Week 11, Sunday)
First to 99.9% chance of Playoffs: Denver (Week 14, Sunday)
First to clinch Playoffs (sort of): Arizona (Week 15, Thursday)
First to clinch Playoffs (for real this time): Arizona, New England, Indianapolis, Denver (Week 15, Sunday)

First team eliminated: Oakland (Week 11, Sunday)

[Week 1]
[Week 2, Thursday]
[Week 2, Sunday]
[Week 2, Final]
[Week 3, Thursday]
[Week 3, Sunday]
[Week 3, Final]
[Week 4, Thursday]
[Week 4, Sunday]
[Week 4, Final]
[Week 5, Thursday]
[Week 5, Sunday]
[Week 5, Final]
[Week 6, Thursday]
[Week 6, Sunday]
[Week 6, Final]
[Week 7, Thursday]
[Week 7, Sunday]
[Week 7, Final]
[Week 8, Thursday]
[Week 8, Sunday]
[Week 8, Final]
[Week 9, Thursday]
[Week 9, Sunday]
[Week 9, Final]
[Week 10, Thursday]
[Week 10, Sunday]
[Week 10, Final]
[Week 11, Thursday]
[Week 11, Sunday]
[Week 11, Final]
[Week 12, Thursday]
[Week 12, Sunday]
[Week 12, Final]
[Week 13, Thursday]
[Week 13, Sunday]
[Week 13, Final]
[Week 14, Thursday]
[Week 14, Sunday]
[Week 14, Final]
[Week 15, Thursday]
[Week 15, Sunday]

2014-12-15

Superbowl XLIX Projection, Week 15, Sunday

New England over Seattle

Seattle took over the NFC, despite currently being a game behind in their division. They're just about even-money to win the NFC West, and that's not accounting for Arizona being down to their third string QB. In the AFC, New England, Indianapolis, and Denver all clinched their divisions, and the AFC North will likely account for the other 3 playoff teams. The 6 AFC teams could actually be locked up by the end of week 16, though with seeding still at stake in the final week. I'm sort of rooting for that, just to see if the NFL would really put the Carolina-Atlanta game in the prime time slot if it is likely to be the only remaining game decide a playoff berth.

TEAMRecordStrengthDivPlyffWCQtrSemiChamp
NE11-30.744++98.91761.42937.14922.638
BAL9-50.70626.98773.90844.15021.81111.7446.621
SEA10-40.70349.70094.88081.43949.10728.73614.777
GB10-40.68151.23296.99978.22544.76824.58911.995
IND10-40.679++57.80528.71213.9657.439
DEN11-30.656++98.50450.43622.16511.245
KC8-60.649-35.86118.7708.0913.7101.853
BUF8-60.630-17.4838.3503.6101.5890.762
PHI9-50.61640.60645.64621.81310.1534.8002.007
DET10-40.60648.76893.49268.54933.15914.8056.055
ARI11-30.60450.300+83.15737.29516.9046.875
HOU7-70.601-4.2841.9370.6840.3060.137
DAL10-40.59659.39468.98436.91616.5637.4312.966
PIT9-50.58933.70772.21332.96812.3664.8652.125
MIA7-70.554-0.0520.0200.0060.0030.001
CIN9-4-10.54839.30678.34031.73210.7823.7991.507
SD8-60.520-17.8606.8462.0740.7060.262
STL6-80.487------
ATL5-90.46232.57032.57010.4283.3071.0590.296
SF7-70.460------
NYG5-90.456------
MIN6-80.455------
NO5-80.45544.77844.77814.0714.3741.3730.376
CLE7-70.446------
CAR5-8-10.36322.65122.6515.4031.2730.3030.062
CHI5-80.331------
WAS3-110.283------
TB2-120.281------
NYJ3-110.244------
TEN2-120.214------
JAC2-120.195------
OAK2-120.193------

First to 10% chance of Superbowl Win: Cincinnati (Week 3, Sunday)

First to 80% chance of Playoffs: Cincinnati (Week 3, Sunday)
First to 90% chance of Playoffs: Indianapolis (Week 7, Sunday)
First to 99% chance of Playoffs: Arizona (Week 11, Sunday)
First to 99.9% chance of Playoffs: Denver (Week 14, Sunday)
First to clinch Playoffs (sort of): Arizona (Week 15, Thursday)
First to clinch Playoffs (for real this time): Arizona, New England, Indianapolis, Denver (Week 15, Sunday)

First team eliminated: Oakland (Week 11, Sunday)

[Week 1]
[Week 2, Thursday]
[Week 2, Sunday]
[Week 2, Final]
[Week 3, Thursday]
[Week 3, Sunday]
[Week 3, Final]
[Week 4, Thursday]
[Week 4, Sunday]
[Week 4, Final]
[Week 5, Thursday]
[Week 5, Sunday]
[Week 5, Final]
[Week 6, Thursday]
[Week 6, Sunday]
[Week 6, Final]
[Week 7, Thursday]
[Week 7, Sunday]
[Week 7, Final]
[Week 8, Thursday]
[Week 8, Sunday]
[Week 8, Final]
[Week 9, Thursday]
[Week 9, Sunday]
[Week 9, Final]
[Week 10, Thursday]
[Week 10, Sunday]
[Week 10, Final]
[Week 11, Thursday]
[Week 11, Sunday]
[Week 11, Final]
[Week 12, Thursday]
[Week 12, Sunday]
[Week 12, Final]
[Week 13, Thursday]
[Week 13, Sunday]
[Week 13, Final]
[Week 14, Thursday]
[Week 14, Sunday]
[Week 14, Final]
[Week 15, Thursday]

2014-12-14

NCAA Football Power Rankings, Week 16

There wasn't much movement today, with only one FBS game taking place, Navy defeating Army. There were also 4 FCS games, and 2 games each at Division II and III, which still affect the rankings, though they aren't likely to change an FBS team as you go further down the divisions due to who plays who. I do think that it's kind of interesting that the playoffs and bowls are already set before the FBS season officially ends. Would the whole thing have to be put on hold for a week if Army or Navy were 11-0 going into this game?

None of my top 25 teams changed positions after these games. The highest-ranked team affected was Utah, who fell one spot behind #28 Cincinnati to #29. Neither team actually played Army or Navy, but they were so closely scored that the subtle shifts in their opponents strengths caused them to swap.

Next up was Air Force, who played both Army and Navy, and jumped up one place to #31 over #32 USC. Georgia Southern got a direct boost from the Navy win, and moved up 1 spot to #39, moving Toledo to #40.

Notre Dame also benefited from the Navy win, moving from #46 up to a tie for #44, and bumping North Carolina State down to #46.

Navy, of course, got the biggest boost, from #70 to #54. As far as relative ordering, a few pairs of the teams they passed swapped places too, including Western Kentucky and Tennessee at #55-56, North Carolina and Arkansas at #57-58, and Houston and Texas at #69-70.

Army interestingly stayed right at #101. They did lose 7 spots in my overall rankings of all 720 teams, but the teams they fell behind were all FCS or below.

Finally, Louisiana-Monroe wrested the #107 spot from Southern Miss, who falls to #108.

I'll probably post weekly updates of these rankings throughout the bowl season, but it's practically a lock my #1 team at the end will be the winner of the playoff, because the strength of 2 victories over 2 top 4 teams should lift any of the 4 of them to the top.

1Florida State13-0
2Alabama12-1
3Ohio State12-1
4Oregon12-1
5Boise State11-2
6TCU11-1
7Marshall12-1
8Baylor11-1
9Georgia Tech10-3
10Missouri10-3
11Wisconsin10-3
12Mississippi State10-2
13Michigan State10-2
14Arizona10-3
15Ole Miss9-3
16Northern Illinois11-2
17UCLA9-3
18Georgia9-3
19Colorado State10-2
20Clemson9-3
21Kansas State9-3
22Nebraska9-3
23Arizona State9-3
24Auburn8-4
25Louisville9-3
26LSU8-4
27Utah State9-4
28Cincinnati9-3
29Utah8-4
30UCF9-3
31Air Force9-3
32USC8-4
33Minnesota8-4
34Duke9-3
35Memphis9-3
36Oklahoma8-4
37Louisiana Tech8-5
38Washington8-5
39Georgia Southern9-3
40Toledo8-4
41BYU8-4
42Texas A&M7-5
43Louisiana-Lafayette8-4
44Maryland7-5
44Notre Dame7-5
46North Carolina State7-5
47Stanford7-5
48East Carolina8-4
49West Virginia7-5
50Boston College7-5
51Rutgers7-5
52Iowa7-5
53Western Michigan8-4
54Navy7-5
55Western Kentucky7-5
56Tennessee6-6
57North Carolina6-6
58Arkansas6-6
59Nevada7-5
60Miami (FL)6-6
61Florida6-5
62Illinois6-6
63Rice7-5
64Virginia Tech6-6
65South Carolina6-6
66UTEP7-5
67Central Michigan7-5
68Arkansas State7-5
69Houston7-5
70Texas6-6
71Oklahoma State6-6
72Bowling Green7-6
73Pittsburgh6-6
74Penn State6-6
75Appalachian State7-5
76Texas State7-5
77Virginia5-7
78Middle Tennessee6-6
79San Diego State6-5
80Fresno State6-7
81Old Dominion6-6
82UAB6-6
83Northwestern5-7
84Kentucky5-7
85Michigan5-7
86California5-7
87Temple6-6
88South Alabama6-6
89Ohio6-6
90Oregon State5-7
91Ball State5-7
92Indiana4-8
93Texas Tech4-8
94Wyoming4-8
95Buffalo5-6
96South Florida4-8
97New Mexico4-8
98Florida International4-8
99Akron5-7
100Syracuse3-9
101Army4-8
102Purdue3-9
103Washington State3-9
104UTSA4-8
105Hawaii4-9
106Vanderbilt3-9
107Louisiana-Monroe4-8
108Southern Miss3-9
109Kansas3-9
110Tulane3-9
111Wake Forest3-9
112San Jose State3-7
113North Texas4-8
114Iowa State2-10
115Florida Atlantic3-9
116Colorado2-10
117Troy3-9
118Eastern Michigan2-10
119UNLV2-11
120Connecticut2-10
121Massachusetts3-9
122Miami (OH)2-10
123Kent State2-9
124Tulsa2-10
125New Mexico State2-10
126SMU1-11
127Georgia State1-11
128Idaho1-10


2014 History and #1s
Week 1 Everybody who was 1-0
Week 2 LSU
Week 3 Oklahoma
Week 4 North Carolina State
Week 5 Nebraska
Week 6 Auburn
Week 7 Mississippi State
Week 8 Florida State
Week 9 Mississippi State
Week 10 Mississippi State
Week 11 Mississippi State
Week 12 Florida State
Week 13 Florida State
Week 14 Florida State
Week 15 Florida State

2014-12-12

Superbowl XLIX Projection, Week 15, Thursday

New England over Green Bay

I hereby demand simulation of ties next year!

Right now I show Arizona having clinched a playoff berth. But, they don't truly clinch until Dallas and Philadelphia end in a non-tie, or some other combination of results this weekend. The odds of a tie are small, so I'll go ahead and say they've clinched. The Rams loss eliminated them, as well as Minnesota, because Minnesota's path to the playoffs involved getting into specific ties involving 3 or more teams at 9-7, including the Rams, who they beat head to head.

TEAMRecordStrengthDivPlyffWCQtrSemiChamp
NE10-30.70598.66499.48195.57557.08133.18118.919
BAL8-50.68834.74665.75039.73520.66211.2686.205
GB10-30.68669.41098.68687.45751.59829.49115.648
SEA9-40.67937.16083.42165.86737.50920.56810.739
IND9-40.66296.67897.77061.80231.67616.1028.403
PHI9-40.63574.01179.42945.19122.01511.1055.264
DEN10-30.63299.50399.96895.40648.50122.14910.841
MIA7-60.6121.02416.2397.7063.4631.5780.739
HOU7-60.6123.32221.72610.8294.7302.1901.025
BUF7-60.6120.3127.4433.5361.5760.7240.339
KC7-60.612-28.37413.8686.0172.7341.280
ARI11-30.60462.840+86.13340.87718.5448.202
DET9-40.60030.59083.84254.59925.47911.6275.093
DAL9-40.57925.98951.32827.18411.8565.2062.168
PIT8-50.57634.78462.10330.67912.3995.1292.215
SD8-50.5450.49737.99116.0115.8902.3020.924
CLE7-60.5134.3719.0583.6891.2460.4510.168
STL6-80.487------
SF7-60.485-3.2941.3110.4520.1630.054
CIN8-4-10.48326.10054.09821.1646.7602.1930.754
ATL5-80.47549.02849.02816.6995.5411.8620.596
MIN6-70.460------
NO5-80.45439.45939.45912.7384.0021.2740.387
NYG4-90.436------
CAR4-8-10.36111.51311.5132.8210.6700.1610.037
CHI5-80.330------
WAS3-100.305------
TB2-110.289------
NYJ2-110.246------
TEN2-110.231------
OAK2-110.222------
JAC2-110.215------

First to 10% chance of Superbowl Win: Cincinnati (Week 3, Sunday)

First to 80% chance of Playoffs: Cincinnati (Week 3, Sunday)
First to 90% chance of Playoffs: Indianapolis (Week 7, Sunday)
First to 99% chance of Playoffs: Arizona (Week 11, Sunday)
First to 99.9% chance of Playoffs: Denver (Week 14, Sunday)
First to clinch Playoffs (sort of): Arizona (Week 15, Thursday)

First team eliminated: Oakland (Week 11, Sunday)

[Week 1]
[Week 2, Thursday]
[Week 2, Sunday]
[Week 2, Final]
[Week 3, Thursday]
[Week 3, Sunday]
[Week 3, Final]
[Week 4, Thursday]
[Week 4, Sunday]
[Week 4, Final]
[Week 5, Thursday]
[Week 5, Sunday]
[Week 5, Final]
[Week 6, Thursday]
[Week 6, Sunday]
[Week 6, Final]
[Week 7, Thursday]
[Week 7, Sunday]
[Week 7, Final]
[Week 8, Thursday]
[Week 8, Sunday]
[Week 8, Final]
[Week 9, Thursday]
[Week 9, Sunday]
[Week 9, Final]
[Week 10, Thursday]
[Week 10, Sunday]
[Week 10, Final]
[Week 11, Thursday]
[Week 11, Sunday]
[Week 11, Final]
[Week 12, Thursday]
[Week 12, Sunday]
[Week 12, Final]
[Week 13, Thursday]
[Week 13, Sunday]
[Week 13, Final]
[Week 14, Thursday]
[Week 14, Sunday]
[Week 14, Final]

2014-12-09

Superbowl XLIX Projection, Week 14, Final

New England over Green Bay

Green Bay beat Atlanta as expected, though maybe not by quite the margin expected. As a result, they hang on to the NFC favorite position. Meanwhile, the NFC South is now led by 2 5-8 teams, and in 3rd there is a 4-8-1 team with an over 11% chance of winning the division. Atlanta and New Orleans still have one head to head game, so the division winner could be as bad as 5-10-1, or 6-10 barring more ties.

I neglected to mention it (or notice it) yesterday, but Denver is the first team to breach the 99.9% mark for chance of making the playoffs. They could clinch the division this week, and allow me to dispense with the silly tracking of 99.99%, etc.

TEAMRecordStrengthDivPlyffWCQtrSemiChamp
NE10-30.70598.66699.48195.57857.08633.18618.969
BAL8-50.68834.76165.76639.74820.66911.2736.224
GB10-30.68669.41298.71387.79652.42830.06115.951
SEA9-40.67948.88684.37567.80939.25621.60611.281
IND9-40.66296.68297.76261.80031.67816.1038.427
PHI9-40.63574.01979.86147.86323.62311.9275.653
DEN10-30.63299.50499.96895.38448.48722.14210.872
MIA7-60.6121.02216.2387.7043.4621.5770.741
HOU7-60.6123.31821.72410.8294.7292.1901.029
BUF7-60.6120.3117.4413.5351.5750.7230.341
KC7-60.612-28.38013.8706.0162.7331.284
DET9-40.60030.58883.77054.98025.61811.8095.172
ARI10-30.58751.11496.95977.30935.02115.2766.483
DAL9-40.57925.98152.42229.34412.9455.7092.377
PIT8-50.57634.78362.10430.70312.4085.1312.224
SD8-50.5450.49637.99516.0095.8892.3000.927
CLE7-60.5134.3709.0563.6881.2450.4500.168
STL6-70.500-0.0770.0290.0100.0040.001
SF7-60.485-3.8161.5250.5220.1890.062
CIN8-4-10.48326.08654.08521.1516.7552.1900.757
ATL5-80.47549.02949.02917.2465.7331.9290.617
MIN6-70.460-0.0060.0020.0010.0000.000
NO5-80.45439.46439.46413.1714.1461.3210.401
NYG4-90.435------
CAR4-8-10.36111.50711.5072.9260.6960.1680.038
CHI5-80.330------
WAS3-100.305------
TB2-110.289------
NYJ2-110.246------
TEN2-110.231------
OAK2-110.221------
JAC2-110.214------

First to 10% chance of Superbowl Win: Cincinnati (Week 3, Sunday)

First to 80% chance of Playoffs: Cincinnati (Week 3, Sunday)
First to 90% chance of Playoffs: Indianapolis (Week 7, Sunday)
First to 99% chance of Playoffs: Arizona (Week 11, Sunday)
First to 99.9% chance of Playoffs: Denver (Week 14, Sunday)

First team eliminated: Oakland (Week 11, Sunday)

[Week 1]
[Week 2, Thursday]
[Week 2, Sunday]
[Week 2, Final]
[Week 3, Thursday]
[Week 3, Sunday]
[Week 3, Final]
[Week 4, Thursday]
[Week 4, Sunday]
[Week 4, Final]
[Week 5, Thursday]
[Week 5, Sunday]
[Week 5, Final]
[Week 6, Thursday]
[Week 6, Sunday]
[Week 6, Final]
[Week 7, Thursday]
[Week 7, Sunday]
[Week 7, Final]
[Week 8, Thursday]
[Week 8, Sunday]
[Week 8, Final]
[Week 9, Thursday]
[Week 9, Sunday]
[Week 9, Final]
[Week 10, Thursday]
[Week 10, Sunday]
[Week 10, Final]
[Week 11, Thursday]
[Week 11, Sunday]
[Week 11, Final]
[Week 12, Thursday]
[Week 12, Sunday]
[Week 12, Final]
[Week 13, Thursday]
[Week 13, Sunday]
[Week 13, Final]
[Week 14, Thursday]
[Week 14, Sunday]

2014-12-08

Superbowl XLIX Projection, Week 14, Sunday

New England over Green Bay

The projections has been the same for weeks, so let's see what's going on with other teams.

The Rams have now won 2 consecutive games as shutouts. Nevermind that the teams are a combined 5-21. They were also eliminated from winning the NFC West yesterday, since Arizona now has 10 wins and they've got 7 losses.

Baltimore has climbed back up to be the second strongest team, even though their record places them a bit lower. Look out for them to outplay their playoff seed if they make it out of the highly successful AFC North.

Kansas City and San Francisco were also eliminated from their divisions, but via tiebreakers. Chicago was eliminated from the playoffs completely after falling to a near-0 chance with their Thursday loss.

TEAMRecordStrengthDivPlyffWCQtrSemiChamp
NE10-30.70598.65999.47895.58657.08333.18119.081
BAL8-50.68834.97265.83239.79620.69411.2856.270
GB9-30.68261.91995.00481.06047.74227.17114.279
SEA9-40.67948.87685.49969.01040.15122.32511.658
IND9-40.66296.67997.76261.80831.68116.1048.484
PHI9-40.63574.00880.23849.30924.65612.5375.943
DEN10-30.63299.50399.96895.37148.47622.13610.946
MIA7-60.6121.02516.2847.7263.4731.5820.749
HOU7-60.6123.32121.72210.8304.7322.1911.037
BUF7-60.6120.3167.5413.5831.5960.7330.348
KC7-60.612-28.38613.8666.0152.7341.293
DET9-40.60038.08184.07256.65526.82012.4295.445
ARI10-30.58751.12497.18377.43635.11215.4956.575
DAL9-40.57925.99253.92630.53213.5866.0392.516
PIT8-50.57634.46361.74730.51812.3355.1022.228
SD8-50.5450.49738.03916.0315.8972.3040.936
CLE7-60.5134.4069.0663.6961.2480.4520.170
STL6-70.500-0.0890.0340.0120.0050.002
SF7-60.485-3.9841.5980.5610.2040.067
ATL5-70.48557.81857.81820.9817.2822.5320.833
CIN8-4-10.48326.16054.17521.1906.7702.1980.767
MIN6-70.460-0.0060.0020.0010.0000.000
NO5-80.45432.80232.80210.9883.4991.1220.340
NYG4-90.436------
CAR4-8-10.3619.3809.3802.3960.5770.1400.032
CHI5-80.330------
WAS3-100.305------
TB2-110.289------
NYJ2-110.246------
TEN2-110.231------
OAK2-110.222------
JAC2-110.215------

First to 10% chance of Superbowl Win: Cincinnati (Week 3, Sunday)

First to 80% chance of Playoffs: Cincinnati (Week 3, Sunday)
First to 90% chance of Playoffs: Indianapolis (Week 7, Sunday)
First to 99% chance of Playoffs: Arizona (Week 11, Sunday)
First to 99.9% chance of Playoffs: Denver (Week 14, Sunday)

First team eliminated: Oakland (Week 11, Sunday)

[Week 1]
[Week 2, Thursday]
[Week 2, Sunday]
[Week 2, Final]
[Week 3, Thursday]
[Week 3, Sunday]
[Week 3, Final]
[Week 4, Thursday]
[Week 4, Sunday]
[Week 4, Final]
[Week 5, Thursday]
[Week 5, Sunday]
[Week 5, Final]
[Week 6, Thursday]
[Week 6, Sunday]
[Week 6, Final]
[Week 7, Thursday]
[Week 7, Sunday]
[Week 7, Final]
[Week 8, Thursday]
[Week 8, Sunday]
[Week 8, Final]
[Week 9, Thursday]
[Week 9, Sunday]
[Week 9, Final]
[Week 10, Thursday]
[Week 10, Sunday]
[Week 10, Final]
[Week 11, Thursday]
[Week 11, Sunday]
[Week 11, Final]
[Week 12, Thursday]
[Week 12, Sunday]
[Week 12, Final]
[Week 13, Thursday]
[Week 13, Sunday]
[Week 13, Final]
[Week 14, Thursday]

2014-12-07

NCAA Football Power Rankings, Week 15

Imagine my surprise to find that I completely agree with the College Football Playoff committee.

Perhaps my agreement is not complete, but in the end the bracket is the same, and since the games are at neutral sites, that's almost all that matters. I have #1 Florida State vs #4 Oregon, whereas the CFP has Oregon at #2 and Florida State #3. The game is in Pasadena, which is closer to Oregon, but probably far enough to be any actual advantage. The other game, Ohio State "at" Alabama in New Orleans is just as the CFP set it up, just with different seeds. I'm not sure if rearranged seeding would have affected the locations of the games, though I could see an argument that the #1 team should get the location closest to home (Florida State in New Orleans in my rankings), and the rest fall into place from there.

So, why did TCU lose its Top 4 spot despite a convincing win? I would argue they never should have been up at #3 in the first place, and in fact I had them 11th last week. However, I do have them ranked higher than Baylor, which was a point of contention for the last few weeks among the pundits. I think the committee dodged most controversy by leaving out the Big 12, though they could have dodged it even better by not putting TCU so high last week.

If Missouri had beaten Alabama, and all other games stayed the same, I would have had them 5th, and the top 4 would have been the same, though Alabama would have fallen to #4. I honestly don't think the committee could have gotten away with choosing a conference non-champion without the champ, though, and both Alabama and Missouri would have been left out. As it is, Missouri fell to a respectable 10th in my ranks, and 16 by the committee. Although, I'm not sure if they care about much after #4.

Finally, congrats to SMU for avoiding the perfect 0-12 season. They even climbed out the cellar up to #126. The bottom team, which should stay there despite any bowl results, is now Idaho, though they're being somewhat punished for only playing 11 games. Them's the breaks, I say.

1Florida State13-0
2Alabama12-1
3Ohio State12-1
4Oregon12-1
5Boise State11-2
6TCU11-1
7Marshall12-1
8Baylor11-1
9Georgia Tech10-3
10Missouri10-3
11Wisconsin10-3
12Mississippi State10-2
13Michigan State10-2
14Arizona10-3
15Ole Miss9-3
16Northern Illinois11-2
17UCLA9-3
18Georgia9-3
19Colorado State10-2
20Clemson9-3
21Kansas State9-3
22Nebraska9-3
23Arizona State9-3
24Auburn8-4
25Louisville9-3
26LSU8-4
27Utah State9-4
28Utah8-4
29Cincinnati9-3
30UCF9-3
31USC8-4
32Air Force9-3
33Minnesota8-4
34Duke9-3
35Memphis9-3
36Oklahoma8-4
37Louisiana Tech8-5
38Washington8-5
39Toledo8-4
40Georgia Southern9-3
41BYU8-4
42Texas A&M7-5
43Louisiana-Lafayette8-4
44Maryland7-5
45North Carolina State7-5
46Notre Dame7-5
47Stanford7-5
48East Carolina8-4
49West Virginia7-5
50Boston College7-5
51Rutgers7-5
52Iowa7-5
53Western Michigan8-4
54Tennessee6-6
55Western Kentucky7-5
56Arkansas6-6
57North Carolina6-6
58Nevada7-5
59Miami (FL)6-6
60Florida6-5
61Illinois6-6
62Rice7-5
63Virginia Tech6-6
64South Carolina6-6
65UTEP7-5
66Central Michigan7-5
67Arkansas State7-5
68Texas6-6
69Houston7-5
70Navy6-5
71Oklahoma State6-6
72Bowling Green7-6
73Pittsburgh6-6
74Penn State6-6
75Appalachian State7-5
76Texas State7-5
77Virginia5-7
78Middle Tennessee6-6
79San Diego State6-5
80Fresno State6-7
81Old Dominion6-6
82UAB6-6
83Northwestern5-7
84Kentucky5-7
85Michigan5-7
86California5-7
87Temple6-6
88South Alabama6-6
89Ohio6-6
90Oregon State5-7
91Ball State5-7
92Indiana4-8
93Texas Tech4-8
94Wyoming4-8
95Buffalo5-6
96South Florida4-8
97New Mexico4-8
98Florida International4-8
99Akron5-7
100Syracuse3-9
101Army4-7
102Purdue3-9
103Washington State3-9
104UTSA4-8
105Hawaii4-9
106Vanderbilt3-9
107Southern Miss3-9
108Louisiana-Monroe4-8
109Kansas3-9
110Tulane3-9
111Wake Forest3-9
112San Jose State3-7
113North Texas4-8
114Iowa State2-10
115Florida Atlantic3-9
116Colorado2-10
117Troy3-9
118Eastern Michigan2-10
119UNLV2-11
120Connecticut2-10
121Massachusetts3-9
122Miami (OH)2-10
123Kent State2-9
124Tulsa2-10
125New Mexico State2-10
126SMU1-11
127Georgia State1-11
128Idaho1-10


2014 History and #1s
Week 1 Everybody who was 1-0
Week 2 LSU
Week 3 Oklahoma
Week 4 North Carolina State
Week 5 Nebraska
Week 6 Auburn
Week 7 Mississippi State
Week 8 Florida State
Week 9 Mississippi State
Week 10 Mississippi State
Week 11 Mississippi State
Week 12 Florida State
Week 13 Florida State
Week 14 Florida State

2014-12-06

Superbowl XLIX Projection, Week 14, Thursday

New England over Green Bay

When I was catching up on my podcasts this week, and listening to the Tuesday episode of Pardon The Interruption, I heard one of the guys mention that Miami was 7-5. I thought to myself that they were actually 6-6, and that would be corrected at the end of the show, as is often done. I didn't think any more of it that day, because I give podcasts only about half my attention while I'm working.

Then, Thursday night, the Bears played and lost. After I ran the numbers, I saw they were 6-7, but had read a story about them falling to 5-8, and being eliminated from the division. Suddenly the Miami mention came back to me, and I feared the worst - bad data.

Luckily, I guess, I found there was only one error, at least in terms of wins and losses. I mistakenly marked Miami's 27-14 win over Chicago backwards, causing all sorts of invalid numbers. The NFC was too strong, and the AFC was too weak. New England should not have been as highly likely to win their division or make the playoffs, even though they're still far and away the favorites.

To save myself from this happening again, my software now generates the current standings, which I can compare to the official standings and ensure a match before posting my numbers..

TEAMRecordStrengthDivPlyffWCQtrSemiChamp
NE9-30.68680.86692.32083.68348.82128.24215.862
GB9-30.68270.20794.65381.90749.16928.50415.619
BAL7-50.66017.84332.50018.6449.6415.0842.709
IND8-40.65894.81695.18561.28132.89717.4499.267
SEA8-40.65843.28973.33253.59929.56815.8608.267
PHI9-30.64684.42191.06371.55638.91220.52710.442
MIA7-50.64012.76039.64223.51511.8836.1063.116
BUF7-50.6266.37421.80012.1515.9402.9691.478
DEN9-30.61890.24897.41084.05742.36619.8729.693
KC7-50.6162.36544.82423.08010.9015.2292.535
HOU6-60.5835.18414.4586.8523.0471.3770.623
DAL9-40.57915.57962.72435.74215.9917.1913.155
ARI9-30.57853.91389.83566.66430.52913.4645.899
SD8-40.5637.38749.27224.81410.5084.4641.929
DET8-40.56129.79371.90043.54318.7168.1203.417
PIT7-50.54015.16428.95314.3125.6192.2360.915
CIN8-3-10.52959.07471.18342.17616.3716.2172.480
CLE7-50.5167.91912.4545.4332.0060.7550.292
SF7-50.5122.78816.3037.5042.8321.1050.412
NO5-70.50955.60755.60722.6458.4203.1641.174
ATL5-70.48542.60342.60316.3635.7592.0390.712
STL5-70.4510.0100.1690.0580.0180.0060.002
MIN5-70.445-0.0200.0060.0020.0010.000
NYG3-90.382------
WAS3-90.352------
CHI5-80.330-0.0000.0000.0000.0000.000
TB2-100.317------
CAR3-8-10.3101.7901.7900.4130.0850.0170.004
TEN2-100.275------
NYJ2-100.256------
JAC2-100.240------
OAK1-110.218------

First to 10% chance of Superbowl Win: Cincinnati (Week 3, Sunday)

First to 80% chance of Playoffs: Cincinnati (Week 3, Sunday)
First to 90% chance of Playoffs: Indianapolis (Week 7, Sunday)
First to 99% chance of Playoffs: Arizona (Week 11, Sunday)

First team eliminated: Oakland (Week 11, Sunday)

[Week 1]
[Week 2, Thursday]
[Week 2, Sunday]
[Week 2, Final]
[Week 3, Thursday]
[Week 3, Sunday]
[Week 3, Final]
[Week 4, Thursday]
[Week 4, Sunday]
[Week 4, Final]
[Week 5, Thursday]
[Week 5, Sunday]
[Week 5, Final]
[Week 6, Thursday]
[Week 6, Sunday]
[Week 6, Final]
[Week 7, Thursday]
[Week 7, Sunday]
[Week 7, Final]
[Week 8, Thursday]
[Week 8, Sunday]
[Week 8, Final]
[Week 9, Thursday]
[Week 9, Sunday]
[Week 9, Final]
[Week 10, Thursday]
[Week 10, Sunday]
[Week 10, Final]
[Week 11, Thursday]
[Week 11, Sunday]
[Week 11, Final]
[Week 12, Thursday]
[Week 12, Sunday]
[Week 12, Final]
[Week 13, Thursday]
[Week 13, Sunday]
[Week 13, Final]

2014-12-04

eBay Wins #146

Today I've got a half dozen 1991 Leafs (Leaves? No, I checked. Pluralizing proper nouns doesn't work that way), picked up for a penny each on eBay.

1991 Leaf
#306 Scott Fletcher
#410 Roger McDowell
#414 Norm Charlton
#416 Chris Nabholz
#424 Dave Rohde
#431 Jamie Quirk
I always like to look up information on the more obscure Cardinals among my somewhat random eBay wins, and Jamie Quirk played just 48 games for the Cardinals, in 1983. He had an 18-year career, but only played 984 games. Over his career, he played every position but Center Field and Pitcher at least once. It seems like you don't see a lot of that anymore, backup catchers playing fielding positions. Occasionally a big hitting starter like Yadier Molina or Buster Posey will get a "day off" - at least for their knees - at first base, or a promising hitter will be outright moved for a new promising catcher, like Joe Torre or Todd Zeile's move to Third Base.

I now have 121 unique cards from the 1991 Leaf set. I already had a copy of Chris Nabholz's card, but the other 5 were new. With only 528 cards in the set, I'm over 22.9% of the way to completion.

eBay Bargain Tracker
Total Cards Bought3223
Total Spent$50.73
Per Card1.574 cents
Change-0.001 cents

2014-12-02

Superbowl XLIX Projection, Week 13, Final

New England over Green Bay

Miami's narrow win over New York didn't change much, but of course bumped up Miami's playoff odds. New England is still the AFC East favorite by a large margin, but Miami has an 11.5% shot at a wildcard now.

I also played around with some scenarios today, and barring any ties, the Rams can actually win the NFC West if there is a 4-way tie at 9-7. It's only 0.01% likely to happen as listed below, but I'll be rooting for it.


TEAMRecordStrengthDivPlyffWCQtrSemiChamp
NE9-30.68689.12795.44487.78451.58829.92416.796
GB9-30.68271.35695.80483.15350.06729.04215.935
BAL7-50.66018.90837.35721.49211.0865.8633.122
IND8-40.65894.94095.48762.70233.67017.8949.491
SEA8-40.65843.27076.02755.97030.88416.5638.642
PHI9-30.64687.43192.44673.18339.84021.01210.703
BUF7-50.6269.08626.20814.6197.1303.5721.777
DEN9-30.61890.24997.47783.66942.48719.9309.717
KC7-50.6162.36448.00624.68511.6195.6062.715
MIA6-60.5891.78711.5085.5772.5251.1620.533
HOU6-60.5835.06015.4957.3913.2711.4840.669
ARI9-30.57853.90691.54668.03731.18813.7426.028
SD8-40.5637.38754.49527.23111.5074.9012.116
DET8-40.56128.64274.56044.48519.1038.2803.492
DAL8-40.55612.56949.93626.69911.3384.8572.027
PIT7-50.54014.96530.63215.1845.9502.3730.971
CIN8-3-10.52958.25373.24743.23916.8046.3962.551
CLE7-50.5167.87414.6456.4282.3630.8960.346
SF7-50.5122.81318.2168.4003.1621.2330.461
NO5-70.50954.25954.26022.2388.2523.1051.154
ATL5-70.48543.81243.81216.9415.9522.1110.739
STL5-70.4510.0100.2550.0890.0270.0090.003
MIN5-70.445-0.0410.0130.0040.0010.000
CHI6-60.3920.0021.1690.3440.0900.0260.007
NYG3-90.383------
WAS3-90.352------
TB2-100.317------
CAR3-8-10.3101.9281.9280.4490.0920.0190.004
TEN2-100.275------
NYJ2-100.256------
JAC2-100.240------
OAK1-110.218------

First to 10% chance of Superbowl Win: Cincinnati (Week 3, Sunday)

First to 80% chance of Playoffs: Cincinnati (Week 3, Sunday)
First to 90% chance of Playoffs: Indianapolis (Week 7, Sunday)
First to 99% chance of Playoffs: Arizona (Week 11, Sunday)

First team eliminated: Oakland (Week 11, Sunday)

[Week 1]
[Week 2, Thursday]
[Week 2, Sunday]
[Week 2, Final]
[Week 3, Thursday]
[Week 3, Sunday]
[Week 3, Final]
[Week 4, Thursday]
[Week 4, Sunday]
[Week 4, Final]
[Week 5, Thursday]
[Week 5, Sunday]
[Week 5, Final]
[Week 6, Thursday]
[Week 6, Sunday]
[Week 6, Final]
[Week 7, Thursday]
[Week 7, Sunday]
[Week 7, Final]
[Week 8, Thursday]
[Week 8, Sunday]
[Week 8, Final]
[Week 9, Thursday]
[Week 9, Sunday]
[Week 9, Final]
[Week 10, Thursday]
[Week 10, Sunday]
[Week 10, Final]
[Week 11, Thursday]
[Week 11, Sunday]
[Week 11, Final]
[Week 12, Thursday]
[Week 12, Sunday]
[Week 12, Final]
[Week 13, Thursday]
[Week 13, Sunday]

2014-12-01

Superbowl XLIX Projection, Week 13, Sunday

New England over Green Bay

Both New England and Arizona lost, and now every team will have at least 3 losses this year. Both teams have fallen back in their playoff chances as well, with both having previously been over 99% likely to make it. They're still in good position, but Arizona is not in the runaway position they once were.

The Rams won a huge shutout, which inflated their strength quite a bit. They're still just barely alive in the playoff hunt.

I mentioned that Minnesota was not actually eliminated from their division on Thursday despite my numbers, because a future Green Bay-Detroit tie could have kept them alive. But Green Bay's win yesterday actually eliminates them from the division. Unfortunately, I now have Tampa Bay allegedly eliminated, but in the same situation. If enough games go the right way, a tie between Atlanta and New Orleans in week 16 could keep Tampa alive. In short, next year's simulations will include ties.

TEAMRecordStrengthDivPlyffWCQtrSemiChamp
NE9-30.68689.30995.64587.89351.66129.96616.817
GB9-30.68271.36495.80983.16250.07129.05115.937
BAL7-50.66019.10137.90821.81011.2555.9523.169
IND8-40.65894.94095.50462.75533.70117.9069.494
SEA8-40.65843.28576.03255.97430.88616.5618.644
PHI9-30.64687.44092.45473.19139.83621.00810.700
BUF7-50.6269.33626.62914.8367.2393.6231.802
DEN9-30.61890.25397.50383.70342.50219.9349.720
KC7-50.6162.36448.33724.83211.6855.6372.730
HOU6-60.5835.06015.8967.5813.3541.5220.689
MIA5-60.5811.3548.7284.1511.8440.8320.374
ARI9-30.57853.89591.54568.03231.19213.7436.030
SD8-40.5637.38454.89427.39911.5734.9282.128
DET8-40.56128.63474.56644.48219.1028.2823.494
DAL8-40.55612.56049.92326.69111.3334.8522.026
PIT7-50.54014.93030.84815.2815.9862.3910.978
CIN8-3-10.52958.10673.33743.28116.8186.4042.553
CLE7-50.5167.86314.7716.4792.3820.9030.349
SF7-50.5122.80918.2098.3933.1611.2320.462
NO5-70.50954.26654.26622.2478.2603.1081.156
ATL5-70.48543.80843.80816.9365.9472.1090.737
STL5-70.4510.0100.2540.0890.0270.0090.003
MIN5-70.445-0.0410.0130.0040.0010.000
CHI6-60.3920.0021.1660.3430.0900.0250.007
NYG3-90.382------
WAS3-90.352------
TB2-100.317------
CAR3-8-10.3101.9271.9270.4480.0910.0190.004
TEN2-100.275------
NYJ2-90.270------
JAC2-100.240------
OAK1-110.218------

First to 10% chance of Superbowl Win: Cincinnati (Week 3, Sunday)

First to 80% chance of Playoffs: Cincinnati (Week 3, Sunday)
First to 90% chance of Playoffs: Indianapolis (Week 7, Sunday)
First to 99% chance of Playoffs: Arizona (Week 11, Sunday)

First team eliminated: Oakland (Week 11, Sunday)

[Week 1]
[Week 2, Thursday]
[Week 2, Sunday]
[Week 2, Final]
[Week 3, Thursday]
[Week 3, Sunday]
[Week 3, Final]
[Week 4, Thursday]
[Week 4, Sunday]
[Week 4, Final]
[Week 5, Thursday]
[Week 5, Sunday]
[Week 5, Final]
[Week 6, Thursday]
[Week 6, Sunday]
[Week 6, Final]
[Week 7, Thursday]
[Week 7, Sunday]
[Week 7, Final]
[Week 8, Thursday]
[Week 8, Sunday]
[Week 8, Final]
[Week 9, Thursday]
[Week 9, Sunday]
[Week 9, Final]
[Week 10, Thursday]
[Week 10, Sunday]
[Week 10, Final]
[Week 11, Thursday]
[Week 11, Sunday]
[Week 11, Final]
[Week 12, Thursday]
[Week 12, Sunday]
[Week 12, Final]
[Week 13, Thursday]